Is the Smeg 2-Slice Toaster Worth It?
Based on tests by Reviewed (Oct 2025) and TechGearLab (Aug 2025). How we score

Save $181Depends. GE 2-Slice for most people.
Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)
Why
Reviewed's take: "If you're looking for a conversation piece, the Smeg 2-Slice Toaster is your pick." It isn't only looks: "As you would expect for the price, it offers excellent toasting." But the same roundup found the GE 2-Slice "toasts evenly and produces three distinct shades of doneness," and named the Cuisinart CPT-122, which toasts "evenly and very quickly," its Best Value. TechGearLab goes further: its lab ranked the Smeg first of 16 toasters (83 of 100), scored the GE and the Cuisinart 62, and listed "uneven toasting coverage" among the GE's cons. So the extra money buys the retro design and, by TechGearLab's measure, better toast. Splurge if the retro look matters to you; save if you want decent toast for far less.
Cheaper alternatives, scored against the Smeg

2-Slice Toaster
Average of 2 testers: Reviewed 9 · TechGearLab 7
From 1 tester: Reviewed
Reviewed lists "Even toasting" and "Consistent toasting" among its pros, the same toasting praise the Smeg gets, plus "Sturdy and well built." Its one con: it "Struggles to pop up English muffins." It's plain stainless steel, with no retro styling. America's Test Kitchen named it its Best Conventional Toaster, but ATK tested a different Smeg (the four-slice), so that test isn't used in this comparison.
Sources: TechGearLab: The Best Toasters (updated Aug. 14, 2025), Reviewed: The Best Two-Slice Toasters of 2026 (updated Oct. 22, 2025), America's Test Kitchen: The Best Toasters (updated Apr. 15, 2026), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing

CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Toaster
Average of 2 testers: Reviewed 10 · TechGearLab 7
From 1 tester: Reviewed
Reviewed's Best Value toaster: "Despite its rock-bottom price, the Cuisinart 2-Slice Compact is beautifully designed and performs well." "When we toasted five 2-slice batches in a row on medium, we got 10 slices of identical toast in about six minutes." It's lightweight plastic, though, and "a fat New York-style bagel is a tight fit."
Sources: TechGearLab: The Best Toasters (updated Aug. 14, 2025), Reviewed: The Best Two-Slice Toasters of 2026 (updated Oct. 22, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing
Common questions
Is the Smeg toaster worth it?
For the look, yes, and Reviewed says it "offers excellent toasting" too. But the same test found the GE 2-Slice toasts evenly and consistently, and named the Cuisinart CPT-122 its Best Value, each for a fraction of the price.
Which Smeg toaster is this?
The two-slice TSF01, the model Reviewed tested. America's Test Kitchen tested Smeg's four-slice long-slot model, which it called "beautiful, expensive, and a bit unreliable."
New verdicts, once a month
Is the expensive one worth it? One email a month with the splurges we've judged since the last one, and the cheaper picks that test as well.
Sources: TechGearLab: The Best Toasters (updated Aug. 14, 2025), Reviewed: The Best Two-Slice Toasters of 2026 (updated Oct. 22, 2025), America's Test Kitchen: The Best Toasters (updated Apr. 15, 2026), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing


