Does expensive mean better?
What 209 head-to-heads show.
We collected 209 head-to-heads: a splurge (a Vitamix, a Le Creuset, a Breville espresso machine) and a cheaper alternative, both rated by the same independent tester. They cover 126 splurges in 39 categories of kitchen and cleaning gear, and 278 tester ratings in all, since some pairs have several testers. Then we asked: how often does the expensive one actually perform better?
84%
of cheaper alternatives scored 9 or 10 out of 10 against the splurge on performance (175 of 209).
55%
did the job as well as the splurge or better: a 10 (115 of 209).
43%
of the splurge’s price: what the typical cheaper alternative costs (the median, at today’s prices).
37%
of pairs with two or more testers saw those testers differ by 2 points or more.
How we scored it
For each tester, we score the cheaper alternative from 1 to 10 against the splurge on performance, read from that tester’s results (star ratings, lab scores or written findings), where 10 means it did the job as well or better. A tester counts only if it rated both products, in one head-to-head test or in its own reviews of each. When several testers compared the same pair, we average them. The testers are America's Test Kitchen, TechGearLab, Tom's Guide, TechRadar, Reviewed, Homes & Gardens, Prudent Reviews and T3. The full method is on How we score.
One thing to keep in mind: these aren’t random cheap products. We chose each alternative from products a tester had already rated alongside the splurge, picking the ones worth considering. So the finding is that a well-tested cheaper option usually exists, not that anything cheaper will do.
How the cheaper alternatives scored
- 10 · as good or better115 (55%)
- 9 of 1060 (29%)
- 8 of 1029 (14%)
- 7 of 104 (2%)
- 6 of 101 (<1%)
No cheaper alternative scored below 6. A score under 9 means at least one tester scored the cheaper one 8 or lower: the splurge did the job better. Each pair’s page says how.
Does paying more for the alternative help?
We grouped the alternatives by how much of the splurge’s price they cost, using today’s prices, and counted how many scored 9 or 10.
- Under 25%82% (28 of 34)
- 25% to 50%81% (61 of 75)
- 50% to 75%88% (42 of 48)
- 75% or more85% (23 of 27)
Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)
Even alternatives costing under a quarter of the splurge’s price scored 9 or 10 in 82% of pairs. Prices move with sales, so these shares shift a little from day to day; the scores don’t.
Where the splurge most often performs better
Categories with at least 4 pairs, sorted by how often the cheaper alternative scored 9 or 10. The top of the list is where testers most often found the expensive one better at the job.
- dutch ovens50% (2 of 4)
- skillets55% (6 of 11)
- cookware sets64% (7 of 11)
- stand mixers67% (4 of 6)
- food processors75% (3 of 4)
- blenders75% (9 of 12)
- coffee makers75% (3 of 4)
- robot vacuums78% (7 of 9)
- electric griddles80% (4 of 5)
- toaster ovens80% (8 of 10)
- toasters82% (9 of 11)
- sauté pans83% (5 of 6)
- citrus juicers83% (5 of 6)
- coffee grinders86% (6 of 7)
- cordless vacuums86% (6 of 7)
- air fryers86% (6 of 7)
- bread machines86% (6 of 7)
- knives & sharpeners94% (15 of 16)
- pressure cookers100% (5 of 5)
- pizza ovens100% (8 of 8)
- espresso machines100% (13 of 13)
- milk frothers100% (4 of 4)
Testers often disagree
54 pairs have scores from two or more testers. In 20 of them (37%), the testers’ scores differ by 2 points or more, and in 12 they agree exactly. That’s why every page shows each tester’s score, not only the average. The widest splits:
| Pair | Each tester’s score |
|---|---|
| Wüsthof Classic Chef's Knife vs Mercer Culinary | America's Test Kitchen 10 · TechGearLab 3 |
| Le Creuset Dutch Oven vs Cuisinart | America's Test Kitchen 9 · Prudent Reviews 9 · TechGearLab 6 |
| Staub Cocotte vs Cuisinart | America's Test Kitchen 9 · TechGearLab 6 |
| Breville Barista Express vs Ninja | America's Test Kitchen 7 · Tom's Guide 10 |
| Baratza Sette 270 vs Smart Grinder Pro | TechGearLab 10 · America's Test Kitchen 7 |
| Gozney Arc vs Ooni Koda 2 | America's Test Kitchen 10 · TechGearLab 7 |
| Smeg 2-Slice Toaster vs Cuisinart CPT-122 | Reviewed 10 · TechGearLab 7 |
| Breville Super Q vs Breville Fresh & Furious | America's Test Kitchen 9 · TechRadar 10 · TechGearLab 7 |
The average score each tester’s results gave the cheaper alternative, for testers with at least 10 pairs. Each tested a different mix of products, so this isn’t a like-for-like ranking of how strict they are:
- America's Test Kitchen9.4 (143 pairs)
- TechGearLab9.0 (53 pairs)
- Tom's Guide9.6 (27 pairs)
- TechRadar9.2 (18 pairs)
- Reviewed9.2 (18 pairs)
- Homes & Gardens8.6 (10 pairs)
What the verdicts say
Our verdict on each splurge reads the tests, price and lifespan together. Of 126 splurges, we rated 51 “Skip it”, 71 “It depends” and 4 “Worth it”. For 9 of them, the original is still our pick.
Limits
- Scores are our reading of each tester’s results (star ratings, lab scores, or written findings). Each pair’s page shows every tester’s score with what it found and a link to the test.
- A 10 means “as good or better”, so these numbers can’t show how often the cheaper one was outright better.
- We left durability out. Most testers don’t measure wear over years, so many durability scores rest on warranties and build notes rather than long-term tests.
- We chose the pairs from products testers had rated side by side, so they aren’t a random sample of products.
- The study grows with the site: the numbers update whenever we add a verdict or a tester.
Use the data
Every pair, with each tester’s score and the link to its test, is in one CSV file. It also has the durability scores each page shows (see Limits). You’re welcome to quote or chart it. Please cite “The Splurge File” and link this page.