Is the Shun Classic 5-Piece Knife Set Worth It?
Based on tests by TechGearLab (Mar 2025). How we score

Save $277Depends. Victorinox 8-Piece for most people.
Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)
Why
TechGearLab named the Shun its Best Upgraded Kitchen Knife Set, 85 of 100: "These knives are the sharpest we tested and held an edge longer than any other in our testing." It scored 9.5 of 10 for cutting and build quality and 9.0 for ergonomics. But it's three knives and a hone, with no bread knife or shears, and TechGearLab's lead tester put it bluntly: "Although the knives are undeniably great, the limited selection lacks versatility." The Victorinox 8-piece, its Best Budget set, scored 83 with five knives, shears and a hone; it scored 9.5 for practicality to the Shun's 6.5, and 8.0 for cutting. Splurge if you want the sharpest knives and already own a bread knife; save if you want a complete set with shears.
Cheaper alternatives, scored against the Shun

8-Piece Knife Block Set
From 1 tester: TechGearLab
From 1 tester: TechGearLab
TechGearLab's Best Budget Kitchen Knife Set: "These knives are sharp, comfortable, and eminently capable of performing any task in the kitchen." It has no utility knife; instead it includes a fillet and a 10-inch slicing knife, which TechGearLab calls "an acceptable tradeoff." Its cons: handle feel varies across the set ("The nylon handle that was comfortable on the chef knife felt awkward on the smaller paring knife"), and the knives sit "noticeably lopsided" in the block. TechGearLab calls the sixth knife a fillet knife; Amazon's listing calls it a 6-inch boning knife.
Sources: TechGearLab: Best Kitchen Knife Sets (updated Mar. 20, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing
Common questions
Is the Shun Classic 5-piece set worth it?
For the knives, yes: TechGearLab found them the sharpest it tested. As a set, it's thin: three knives and a hone, with no bread knife or shears. The Victorinox 8-piece scored nearly as high overall (83 vs 85) with a fuller set.
New verdicts, once a month
Is the expensive one worth it? One email a month with the splurges we've judged since the last one, and the cheaper picks that test as well.
Sources: TechGearLab: Best Kitchen Knife Sets (updated Mar. 20, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing




