Skip to main content

Is the All-Clad D5 12-Inch Fry Pan Worth It?

Based on tests by America's Test Kitchen (Jun 2025). How we score

All-Clad D5 Stainless Brushed 12" Fry Pan (SD55112)
All-Clad D5 12"
$199.95
Our pickAll-Clad D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with LidSave $80
All-Clad D3 12"
$119.95

Skip it. Get the All-Clad D3 12".

Our pick
All-Clad D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with Lid
$119.95
Not worth the price
All-Clad D5 Stainless Brushed 12" Fry Pan
$199.95

Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)

Why

America's Test Kitchen rated the five-ply D5 Recommended but put it below All-Clad's own three-ply D3: it's "a bit heavier and smaller and performs a little more sluggishly, transferring heat more slowly." ATK's conclusion: "For the price and with no lid, we don't see the point of choosing this model over the d3 pan." The D3 12-inch, ATK's longtime winner, comes with a lid and usually costs less. Tramontina's tri-ply 12-inch costs far less still, with a narrower cooking surface.

Cheaper alternatives, scored against the All-Clad D5 12"

Our pick
All-Clad D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with Lid
All-Clad

D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with Lid

$119.95
Performance vs the All-Clad D5 12"10/10 Matches

From 1 tester: America's Test Kitchen

Durability vs the All-Clad D5 12"9/10 Close

From 1 tester: America's Test Kitchen

America's Test Kitchen's winning stainless skillet, rated higher than the D5 for performance and ease of use, and it includes a lid. "We appreciate the wide cooking surface and low, flaring sides that encourage excellent browning and evaporation." "It resisted warping and withstood thermal shock and outright abuse with nary a scratch or dent." ATK on the D5: "For the price and with no lid, we don't see the point of choosing this model over the d3 pan."

Tester's ratings, out of 3 stars (higher rating in green)
CriterionAll-Clad D5 12"All-Clad D3 12"
Performance2.5/33/3
Ease of use2.5/33/3
Cleanup/durability3/33/3

From America's Test Kitchen: The Best Stainless-Steel Skillets (updated June 25, 2025)

Sources: America's Test Kitchen: The Best Stainless-Steel Skillets (updated June 25, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing

Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad 12" Fry Pan with Helper Handle (80116/057DS)
Tramontina

Tri-Ply Clad 12" Fry Pan with Helper Handle

$57.13
~$2/yr est.
Performance vs the All-Clad D5 12"8/10 Close

From 1 tester: America's Test Kitchen

Durability vs the All-Clad D5 12"8/10 Close

From 1 tester: America's Test Kitchen

Rated Recommended with reservations by America's Test Kitchen, a notch below the D5 for performance (2 vs 2.5 of 3). "This sturdy pan barely dented and didn’t warp, making it a good choice, especially if you own a flat-topped stove." But "Its cooking surface was the narrowest in the lineup, so four steaks or eight pieces of chicken were crowded and didn’t cook as evenly." Like the D5, it has no lid.

Tester's ratings, out of 3 stars (higher rating in green)
CriterionAll-Clad D5 12"Tramontina
Performance2.5/32/3
Ease of use2.5/32.5/3
Cleanup/durability3/32.5/3

From America's Test Kitchen: The Best Stainless-Steel Skillets (updated June 25, 2025)

Sources: America's Test Kitchen: The Best Stainless-Steel Skillets (updated June 25, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing

Common questions

All-Clad D5 or D3?

America's Test Kitchen prefers the D3: the five-ply D5 heats more slowly, is smaller and heavier, and has no lid. ATK's verdict: "For the price and with no lid, we don't see the point of choosing this model over the d3 pan."

New verdicts, once a month

Is the expensive one worth it? One email a month with the splurges we've judged since the last one, and the cheaper picks that test as well.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

Sources: America's Test Kitchen: The Best Stainless-Steel Skillets (updated June 25, 2025), Manufacturer specs via Amazon listing

More skillets verdicts

Our pickAll-Clad D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with Lid
All-Clad
$119.95
Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad 12" Fry Pan with Helper Handle (80116/057DS)
Tramontina
$57.13

Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)

Worth it. Buy the All-Clad.

Runner-up: Tramontina vs the All-Clad
Performance
7/10 Behind
Durability
8/10 Close
Only alternativeFull verdict
Le Creuset Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 12" Fry Pan (SSP2000-30)
Le Creuset Stainless 12"
$163.96
Our pickAll-Clad D3 Stainless 12" Fry Pan with LidSave $44
All-Clad D3 12"
$119.95

Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)

Skip it. Get the All-Clad D3 12".

All-Clad D3 12" vs the Le Creuset Stainless 12"
Performance
10/10 Matches
Durability
10/10 Matches
Only alternativeFull verdict
Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Frying Pan, 10.5"
Caraway
$106
Our pickGreenPan Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 10" Frying Pan with Lid (CC000670-001)Save $6
GreenPan
$99.99

Amazon prices as of Nov 22, 2:44 PM EST (details)

Depends. GreenPan for most people.

Splurge if you want its look.

GreenPan vs the Caraway
Performance
8/10 Close
Durability
8/10 Close
Only alternativeFull verdict
No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

No brand deals, no paid rankings. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, whichever product you pick. How we score · About · Splurge gifts · Does expensive mean better? · Privacy

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

© 2026 The Splurge File